13 Best Authentic Vegan Pizza New York City Joints

13 Best Authentic Vegan Pizza New York City Joints Caavakushi

NYC Leading The Plant-Based Pizza Revolution

The Caavakushi team has found something incredible happening in the concrete jungle. New York City isn’t just the capital of the world; it has officially become the global sanctuary for the vegan pizza New York City enthusiast. Gone are the days of sad, cheeseless vegetable pies. Today, we are seeing a total plant-based revolution that is actually challenging the traditional dollar slice status quo.

Statistically, the shift is undeniable. The global vegan pizza market is projected to grow at a CAGR of 9.44% through 2034, with North America currently dominating 39.13% of the total pizza market share as of 2025 (Our source: Zion Market Research). The Caavakushi team feels that NYC is the beating heart of this growth. In fact, NYC recently scored an impressive 88/100 on the vegan city index, specifically for its menu clarity and plant-based commitment (Our source: Spinach Guide).

From The Street Corner To The White Tablecloth

The Caavakushi team has seen how NYC offers a beautiful paradox: you can find a life-changing vegan pizza New York City slice at a gritty window in Brooklyn or a refined, cashew-cheese masterpiece in a Manhattan bistro. We’ve found that the best joints are those that treat vegan cheese as an artisanal craft, not an afterthought.

The Caavakushi Elite 13 Vegan PIZZA New York City List

1. Double Zero (Manhattan)

Matthew Kenney’s upscale gem. The Caavakushi team believes their plant-based truffle & mushroom pizza with cashew cream is a masterclass in elegance.

2. Two Boots (Multiple Locations)

A creative powerhouse! They rank #1 for vegan commitment with a 0.79 dish quality score (Our source: Spinach Guide).

3. Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop (Greenpoint)

Famous for their Vegan Freddy Prinze. The Caavakushi team absolutely loves the sesame seed bottom on their thick Sicilian squares.

4. Vito’s Slices and Ices (Midtown)

This place is a classic NYC hole-in-the-wall. They offer a plant-based mozzarella slice that satisfies that authentic thin-crust craving.

5. Coletta (Chelsea)

Upscale Italian dining where the plant-based meat toppings are so realistic, the Caavakushi team suggests double-checking—it’s that good!

6. Artistic Pizza (Greenwich Village)

The Caavakushi team feels their Beyond Shrooms & Spinach pie is the perfect fuel for a late-night stroll through the Village.

7. Unregular Pizza (Union Square)

This spot is known for their Roman-style squares. Their vegan options are creative, crunchy, and highly rated for fast service.

8. John’s of Bleecker Street

While historic, the Caavakushi team did notice they are increasingly accommodating, though you’ll often go cheese-free here for that perfect coal-fired crust.

9. Williamsburg Pizza

Their vegan cup n char pepperoni is a game-changer for those who miss the spicy, oily kick of traditional deli meats.

10. NY Pizza Suprema

Right by MSG. The Caavakushi team thinks their vegan marinara with extra garlic is a sleeper hit.

11. Pizza Collective

Scoring a 5.0/5.0 for vegan menu quality, this is a hidden gem for Sicilian-style lovers (Our source: Spinach Guide).

12. Scarr’s Pizza

Known for milling their own flour. The Caavakushi team noticed their vegan cheese option pairs perfectly with their heritage-grain crust.

13. My Pie Pizzeria Romana

Incredible vegan Roman-style slices that offer a unique, airy crunch you won’t find anywhere else.

The Cheez Factor

The Caavakushi team has found that the secret lies in the evolution of the fats. With 68% of the global population experiencing lactose malabsorption, the demand for cashew, oat, and coconut-based cheeses has moved from a niche to a necessity (Our source: Fortune Business Insights). In NYC, this has led to a totally original culinary art form where the cheese actually stretches and browns just like the real thing.

A Final Slice Of Advice For The Vegan Pizza New York City Scene

New York has proven that you don’t need a cow to have a world class pizza. You can have the culture, the thin crust fold, and the rich tomato sauce without the ethical compromise. So just remember whether you’re grabbing a square on the go or sitting down for a candlelit vegan feast, these 13 plant-based pizza joints have redefined the NYC food map.

The Caavakushi team wants to know: Are you a thin crust folder or a thick square crust-lover?

Vegan Resources

Tell Us How You Feel

We want to know how you feel about the site, blog articles, and our recipes. Comment below and let us know your thoughts. Snap a quick picture or video clip of your recreation of our recipes and tag us on social media #Caavakushi #Caavakushirecipe #Caavakushimeal. We can’t wait to see how you added your special touch to our recipes. Help a fellow vegan out by posting your recipes on our vegan forum and make some new plant-based friends. Our podcast has something for everyone, from vegan activists to vegan businesses and plant-based celebrities.

If you like it, help us out by letting us know by leaving a review and 5 stars. Thanks in advance! (really appreciate it.) Oh, and we almost forgot to tell you that we’re giving away our 7-day high-protein vegan meal plan for free for a limited time only when you sign up for our vegan newsletter. Get yours now before it’s too late!

Leave a Reply